• Contact us
  • Steel Construction Certification Scheme
  • Members Area
  • Login

    Lost your password? Register
BCSA Master LogoBCSA Master LogoBCSA Master LogoBCSA Master Logo
  • About us
    • BCSA Group of Companies
    • Our Team
  • Member Directories
    • Buildings Directory
    • Bridgeworks Register
    • Industry
    • Corporate
    • Benefits of using a BCSA member
    • Sustainability Charter
      • Sustainability Charter Members
    • BIM Charter
      • BIM Charter Members
  • Join BCSA
    • Membership Categories
      • Steelwork Contractor Buildings
      • Steelwork Contractor Bridgeworks
      • Industry
      • Corporate
    • Member Benefits
  • Resources
    • COVID-19
    • Process and Technical
      • Bridges preliminary design
      • Coatings Advisory Service
      • Committees and Working Groups
      • National Structural Steelwork Specification
      • Steel Industry Guidance Notes (SIGNS)
      • Sustainability
        • SteelConstruction.info – Sustainability
        • Steel construction – Carbon Credentials
        • Sustainability Charter
        • Carbon Footprint Tool
        • Bridges Carbon Calculator
      • Steel Construction Building Information Modelling (BIM) Charter
      • Webinars
    • Law and Contracts
      • Annotated Contracts
      • Contractual Handbook
      • Construction Act Amendments
      • Helplines and Other Schemes
      • Insurances
      • Model Letters and Other Documents
      • Minimum Standards of Contract
      • Sub-contract Terms and Conditions
    • Commercial
      • Cost information
      • Daywork rates survey results
      • Economic reports
      • IR35 Off-Payroll Working
      • Prices and Lead Times
      • Reverse VAT
      • State of Trade
    • Health and Safety
      • ‘Be Selfish Be Safe’ Information Sheets
      • Behavioural Based Safety
      • Construction Skills Setting Out Video
      • Electromagnetic Fields
      • Erection Guides
        • BCSA Guides
        • Metal Deck Health and Safety Guides
      • Health and Safety Information
      • Lifting Operations
      • Loading and Unloading Vehicles
      • Mobile Elevating Work Platforms (MEWPs)
      • Office, Factory and Site
      • Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)
      • Risk Assessments
      • Safe Site Handover Certificate
      • Safety Schemes in Procurement (SSIP)
      • About Tool Box Talks
        • Tool Box Talks
      • BCSA CHAS Discount offer
    • Training
      • CRAFT Certificate Introduction to Module Learning
      • CRAFT Structural Steelwork Fabricator Welder
      • CRAFT Metal Decking Installer
      • CRAFT Structural Steel Detailer
      • CRAFT Surface Treatment
      • Bolting Competency
      • Welding Competency
    • Steel for Life
    • Structural Steel Design Awards
      • Award
        • Tintagel Footbridge, Cornwall
        • 52 Lime Street, London
        • The Curragh Racecourse Redevelopment, Kildare
        • Bath Schools of Art and Design
        • A14 Cambridge to Huntingdon Improvement Scheme
        • Brunel Building, London
      • Commendation
        • Mary Elmes Bridge, Cork City
        • The Post Building, London
        • Centre Building, London School of Economics
        • Waterloo Station Roof Infill
        • One Bartholomew, Barts Square, London
        • The Standard Hotel, London
      • Merit
        • The Gravity Bar, Guinness Storehouse, Dublin
        • Scarborough Footbridge, York
      • National Finalists
        • One Bank Street, Canary Wharf
        • Barton Square, intu Trafford Centre, Manchester
        • Boeing GoldCare Aircraft Hangar, Gatwick Airport
        • The Balfour, Kirkwall, Orkney
        • National Infrastructure Laboratory, University of Southampton
        • The Wave, Coventry
        • Drake Circus The Barcode, Plymouth
        • Bridgewater Place Wind Amelioration Scheme, Leeds
      • Judges 2020
      • SSDA 2019
        • Award
          • Wimbledon No.1 Court
          • Taplow Riverside Footbridge
          • Coal Drops Yard, London
          • Tombola HQ, Sunderland
          • Tottenham Hotspur Football Club, New Stadium
        • Commendation
          • Battersea Arts Centre
          • Fen Court, London
          • Chiswick Park Footbridge
          • Ingenuity House, Birmingham
          • Neuron Pod, London
          • Royal Academy of Music, London
        • Merit
          • The Macallan Distillery
          • G W Annenberg Performing Arts Centre
          • Greatham Creek Seal Hide, Middlesbrough
          • Telford Central Footbridges
        • National Finalists
          • 160 Old Street, London
          • Aga Khan Centre, London
          • Ely Southern Bypass
          • Project Mint at The O2
          • Kettner’s Townhouse & Soho House Greek Street
  • Events and Meetings
  • News
  • Shop
  • Members Area
  • Reverse VAT
  • BREXIT
  • COVID-19
  • HS2 Collaboration Hub Webinar
0
  • Home
  • News
  • General
  • President’s Column (September 2020)

President’s Column (September 2020)

16th September 2020

John Blackwell, Rowecord Engineering’s long-standing charismatic former MD, used to say “steelwork contracting is all about managing risk”. John’s words are as true today as they always have been, probably more so. All too often steelwork contractors are being forced into taking on the temporary stability of the steelwork during erection with no allowance being made at tender stage for this crucial part of the building’s life. This is a recipe for a ‘race to the bottom’ and in my experience those who sometimes win this work are the least able to design the temporary stability required during erection.

The CDM Regulations make it clear that it is the designer’s responsibility to provide at least one safe sequence of erection for the structure which includes consideration of any requirements for temporary stability and the safe dismantling of the structure at end of life. Safety is a crucial consideration during steel erection as part erected structures can be vulnerable to collapse.

Undoubtably the hardening of the insurance market following the tragic fire at Grenfell Tower and the general increase in professional indemnity (PI) claims has pushed up the cost of PI insurance, in some cases trebling historical premiums. This has caused some designers to reduce their risk by off-loading the temporary stability of the structure during erection to the steelwork contractor. We have all seen increases in the amount of design responsibility passed down to Tier 2 contractors from consultants, which has increased our potential liability.

For multi-storey buildings the flooring system in its final state is often intended to act as the ‘magic diaphragm’, 100% stiff as modelled, sometimes with very unusual aspects in length and breadth coupled with sometimes more holes in the floor plate than a Swiss cheese. Again, not much consideration as to how the structure is safe during construction. Many steelwork companies claim that this is fine, they can handle the additional responsibility. However, I haven’t met many yet that charge and recover a pound for every pound expended in taking this risk on, never mind the additional design, fabrication, erection and removal of necessary temporary bracing.

A similar temporary situation occurs with precast concrete floor planks. The most critical condition here can occur during the placing of the concrete units and consideration must be given to ensuring that the asymmetric loading conditions that can arise are carefully controlled to prevent the twisting or failure of the supporting beams.

The old national standard, BS 5950, contained a clause that made it clear that issues such as temporary stability are the responsibility of the designer. Clause 2.1.1.2 on overall stability states ‘The designer who is responsible for the overall stability of the structure should be clearly identified.’ This applies equally to the temporary stability of the structure during erection and, taken together with the CDM Regulations, places the responsibility on the designer to provide a safe sequence of erection. Perhaps a similar statement would have been useful in the Eurocodes.

Mark Denham, BCSA President

British Constructional Steelwork Association
4 Whitehall Court, Westminster, London SW1A 2ES
email: postroom@steelconstruction.org | Tel: 020 7839 8566
BCSA logo Supporting the UK Steelwork Contractors for over a Century
© All Rights Reserved BCSA – The British Constructional Steelwork Association Ltd.

This website uses cookies to improve your user experience. To find out more about the cookies we use, see our privacy policy. I accept